Before and After: Sally's Dress by Hayakain

I can't really compare them, as you were going for totally different things in each picture.

The old one is a more conventional colouring style with much more details but the new one is going for a more simplistic and easier to draw style.

What would make the best look in my opinion is the colouring style of the old one with the line art of the new one.

Then again can't really compare as they are so different.

I'm actually torn between which I like more because well, they both were meant to achieve different visual looks.

INTERESTING! 

The only thing the newer one has better is shading on the dress. Everything about the older one is better.

-lineart is rougher

-that dress still defies gravity. It needs something to hold it up, like shoulder straps, or make it end higher up the breasts so the breasts will hold it up.

-the front/back is inconsistant. In the backside the middle is higher up and the butt is farther down than the front side. I recommend copy and paste the front side and flip it. Then use that as an outline for the back side. That way both will be consistant.

-even less room for organs. Where the hell is her stomach?

-life-less eyes. The way the eyes are drawn makes her look lifeless, darker pupils will fix that really easily.

-tumor thighs. There is no way she could walk with such large thighs, they would keep hitting eachother. Tone it down a bit.

-her tail is slapped onto her dress. The tail starts at the tailbone, which is right where the start of the butt is. Move the cut of the dress down or the butt/tail higher and it will be fixed.

-the black lines on her butt make it look like the dress is wedged up there, it looks unnatural.

The new one looks like it was outlined in MS paint... Yeah, old one wins by a long one...

strange but - old is better.

Great remake!

I have to admit, the Before one looks more detailed. and cleaner.

i like bove styles, but the left one looks more bitchy to say and the right one more tender

Nice improvement.

I like the hair better in the older one, but I like how you've got more line variation now.

Looks Great ^^

I love it man ^^

i actually like the lineart of the left one a little more honestly

Beauty  

The scary thing is that now it's even more anatomically incorrect. 83

I like the figure that this Sally cuts, but shes missing the cross :3

My opinion? The dress improved some, but that's it.

Damn.... she looks sexy! ^^

She looks a lot nicer then the old version.

Neat!

Good lord, what keeps that on?
MT

Very hot and sexy!

The time has gone by Fast.

new one is totally better